Adjustable Dumbbells vs Fixed: Which Wins the Home Gym Battle?

Get the rundown on Adjustable Dumbbells vs Fixed. Our quick guide compares their features, benefits, and suitability for your workout regime!

Russell Richardson Jr

01 Dec 2023

When it comes to building a home gym, one of the most important pieces of equipment you'll need is a set of dumbbells. But with so many options available, it can be tough to decide between adjustable dumbbells and fixed dumbbells.

Both have their pros and cons, and the right choice for you will depend on your personal preferences and workout goals.

Adjustable dumbbells are a popular choice for home gyms because they allow you to easily change the weight of the dumbbell with just a turn of a dial or a slide of a pin. This makes them a great space-saving option, as you won't need to have a whole rack of different weights taking up valuable floor space.

On the other hand, fixed dumbbells are typically more durable and can withstand heavier use over time. They also have a classic look and feel that some people prefer over the more modern design of adjustable dumbbells.

Disclosure: We only recommend things we’ve personally used or come highly recommended by trusted peers. Using one of our referral links might give us a small commission which helps support this website at no additional cost to you. If you’d like to learn more check out our disclaimer page.

Key Takeaways

The right choice between adjustable and fixed dumbbells depends on your personal preferences, workout goals, and workout style.
Adjustable dumbbells are a space-saving option, while fixed dumbbells are typically more durable.
Both types of dumbbells have their pros and cons, so it's important to consider your own needs and preferences before making a decision.

Understanding Dumbbells

Dumbbells are a type of weightlifting equipment that is commonly used for strength training exercises.

They come in different shapes and sizes, but they all have one thing in common: they are designed to be held in one hand.

Types of Dumbbells

There are two main types of dumbbells: fixed and adjustable.

Fixed dumbbells are the traditional type of dumbbell that most people are familiar with. They come in a range of weights, from light to heavy, and are usually made of cast iron or steel, usually with a rubber coating.
Adjustable dumbbells, on the other hand, have a mechanism that allows you to change the weight of the dumbbell. They typically come with a set of weight plates that can be added or removed to adjust the overall weight of the dumbbell.

Adjustable Dumbbells

If you're looking to invest in a pair of dumbbells for your home gym, you might be wondering whether to go for adjustable dumbbells or fixed dumbbells.

In this section, we will discuss adjustable dumbbells and their features, benefits, and some of the best adjustable dumbbells available in the market.

Features of Adjustable Dumbbells

Adjustable dumbbells are a pair of dumbbells that allow you to change the weight of the dumbbell by adding or removing weight plates.

The adjustment mechanism can be different for different models. Some of the common adjustment mechanisms include selectorized dumbbells, dial-a-weight dumbbells, and twist-lock dumbbells.

Selectorized dumbbells: These dumbbells have a weight selection mechanism that allows you to choose the desired weight by moving a pin. Some examples of selectorized dumbbells include Bowflex SelectTech and PowerBlock dumbbells.
Dial-a-weight dumbbells: These dumbbells have a dial that you can turn to select the desired weight. Examples of dial-a-weight dumbbells include Ironmaster Quick-Lock dumbbells and NordicTrack dumbbells.
Plate loaded adjustable dumbbells: These dumbbells have a twist-lock mechanism that secures the weight plates in place. Examples of twist-lock dumbbells include Yes4All adjustable dumbbells and CAP Barbell adjustable dumbbells.

Benefits of Adjustable Dumbbells

Adjustable dumbbells offer several benefits over traditional fixed dumbbells:

Space-saving: Adjustable dumbbells take up less space than fixed dumbbells as you don't need to have a set of dumbbells for each weight.
Cost-effective: Buying a pair of adjustable dumbbells can be more cost-effective than buying a set of fixed dumbbells as you can adjust the weight as required.
Versatile: With adjustable dumbbells, you can perform a wide range of exercises by adjusting the weight.
Easy to use: Adjustable dumbbells are easy to use and require minimal setup time.

Best Adjustable Dumbbells

Here are some of the best adjustable dumbbells available on the market:

Bowflex SelectTech 552 | 5-52.5 lbs
Selectorized PowerBlock Elite | 5-70 lbs
Ironmaster Quick-Lock | 5-75 lbs
Dial-a-weight Yes4All Adjustable Dumbbells | 40-200 lbs
NordicTrack Select-A-Weight | 10-55 lbs

Fixed Dumbbells

Fixed dumbbells are the traditional type of dumbbell that come in a set weight. They are a popular choice for home gyms because they are easy to use and require no adjustment.

Here are some features, benefits, and some of the best fixed dumbbells available on the market.

Features of Fixed Dumbbells

Fixed dumbbells are available in a variety of shapes and sizes. The most common types are hexagonal and round.

Hexagonal dumbbells are popular because they do not roll around, making them a safer option.
Round dumbbells are more traditional and are more commonly available to purchase.

Benefits of Fixed Dumbbells

Fixed dumbbells are a great option for those who want a simple and effective workout.

They are easy to use and require no adjustment. This means that you can quickly switch between exercises and change weights without wasting time adjusting the weight.

Fixed dumbbells are also a more affordable option than adjustable dumbbells, making them a popular choice for home gyms.

Best Fixed Dumbbells

If you are looking for the best fixed dumbbells, there are a few options to consider.

Regular dumbbells are a great option for those who want a simple and affordable workout.

They are available in a wide range of weights and are easy to use.
Hexagonal dumbbells are a safer option because they do not roll around.
They are a great option for those who want to do exercises that require them to place the dumbbells on the ground.
Single dumbbells are a good option for those who want to buy just one dumbbell. They are a more affordable option than buying a set of dumbbells.

Here are some of the best adjustable dumbbells available on the market:

Space Considerations

When it comes to home gyms, space is often a major consideration.

If you have limited space, adjustable dumbbells may be the better option for you.

They take up much less space than a full set of fixed dumbbells, as you can adjust the weight on each dumbbell as needed.
This means you can have a wide weight range of weights without having to store multiple sets of dumbbells.

On the other hand, if you have a lot of space and prefer the traditional feel of fixed dumbbells, they may be the better option for you.

Fixed dumbbells take up more space than adjustable dumbbells, but they also come in a wider range of weights and often feel more stable when lifting heavier weights.

When it comes to storage space, adjustable dumbbells are easier to store than fixed dumbbells.

Many adjustable dumbbell sets come with a storage rack, which can help keep your home gym organized and tidy. Fixed dumbbells, on the other hand, may require a larger storage solution, such as a weight rack or shelf.

Weight Considerations

When it comes to weight, both adjustable and fixed dumbbells have their advantages and disadvantages.

With fixed dumbbells, you have a set weight that cannot be adjusted, which means you need to purchase different sets of dumbbells to accommodate different exercises that require different weights.
Adjustable dumbbells allow you to change the amount of weight you're lifting by simply turning a dial or sliding a pin.

If you're looking for heavier weights, fixed dumbbells are the way to go. Fixed dumbbells can be found in heavier weights than adjustable dumbbells, which usually have a maximum weight of around 50 pounds per dumbbell.

However, if you're just starting out with weightlifting or don't need to lift extremely heavy weights, adjustable dumbbells can be a more cost-effective and space-saving option.

When it comes to the amount of weight you can lift, both types of dumbbells offer a similar weight range.

Adjustable dumbbells usually have a weight range that starts at 2 or 5 pounds and goes up to around 50 pounds per dumbbell.
Fixed dumbbells, on the other hand, are available in a wider range of weights, but you need to purchase different sets of dumbbells to accommodate different exercises that require different weights.

The weight increments on adjustable dumbbells can vary depending on the model, but most adjustable dumbbells allow you to increase or decrease the weight in increments of 2.5 or 5 pounds.

Fixed dumbbells, on the other hand, have a fixed weight that cannot be adjusted.

Ease of Use

When it comes to ease of use, both adjustable and fixed dumbbells have their advantages and disadvantages.

Adjustable dumbbells generally are user-friendly because they allow you to quickly and easily change the weight of the dumbbell with a simple adjustment mechanism.

This means you don't have to spend time swapping out different weights or storing multiple sets of dumbbells.
Some adjustable dumbbells even come with a dial or selector pin that allows you to change the weight in small increments, giving you more control over your workout.

On the other hand, fixed dumbbells are easier to use once you have selected the weight you need.

There is no adjustment mechanism to worry about, and the weight is fixed in place, so you don't have to worry about it shifting or moving during your workout.
This can be particularly helpful for certain exercises that require a lot of stability, such as bench presses or overhead presses.

In terms of adjustment mechanism, adjustable dumbbells usually come with either a dial or a selector pin.

The dial allows you to adjust the weight by simply turning the dial to the desired weight, while the selector pin requires you to manually move the pin to the correct weight.

The dial is generally considered easier to use, as it allows for quicker and more precise adjustments.

When it comes to locking mechanisms, adjustable dumbbells typically use either a clamp or a twist-lock mechanism to hold the weight plates in place. The clamp is generally considered easier to use, as it requires less effort to secure the weight plates in place.

However, the twist-lock mechanism is generally considered more secure, as it provides a tighter hold on the weight plates and reduces the risk of them coming loose during your workout.

Durability

When it comes to durability, fixed dumbbells are generally considered to be more durable than adjustable dumbbells. This is because fixed dumbbells are made from a single piece of metal, whereas adjustable dumbbells have moving parts that can wear out over time.

Fixed dumbbells are also less likely to break or malfunction during use, as there are no moving parts that can fail. This makes them a safer option for heavy lifting and intense workouts where you might need to drop the weights.

That being said, the durability of adjustable dumbbells can vary depending on the brand and model. Higher-end adjustable dumbbells are often made from high-quality materials and designed to last for years, while cheaper models may be less durable and more prone to breaking or malfunctioning.

If you're looking for the most durable option, fixed dumbbells are likely the way to go. However, if you're willing to invest in a high-quality set of adjustable dumbbells, they can be just as durable and long-lasting as fixed dumbbells.

Exercises and Workouts

When it comes to exercises and workouts, both adjustable dumbbells and fixed dumbbells can provide a great strength training and weight training experience.

Both types of dumbbells can be used to perform a variety of exercises and full-body workouts, depending on your fitness goals and preferences.

With adjustable dumbbells, you have the advantage of being able to change the weight of the dumbbell quickly and easily, allowing you to perform a variety of exercises with a single set of dumbbells.

This can save you time and space in your home gym. With fixed dumbbells, you will need to have a set of dumbbells in different weight increments to perform a variety of exercises.

Both adjustable and fixed dumbbells can be used to perform a variety of exercises, including bicep curls, tricep extensions, shoulder presses, chest presses, rows, lunges, squats, and deadlifts.

With a variety of exercises available, you can create a full-body workout that targets different muscle groups and helps you achieve your fitness goals.

One advantage of using adjustable dumbbells is the ability to perform different exercises with the same set of dumbbells.

For example, you can perform bicep curls with a lighter weight and then quickly adjust the weight to perform tricep extensions with a heavier weight. This can save you time and make your workouts more efficient.

In contrast, fixed dumbbells offer a more traditional weight training experience, where you use a set of dumbbells in different weight increments to perform different exercises. This can be beneficial for those who prefer a more structured workout routine and want to focus on specific muscle groups.

Personal Preferences and Considerations

When it comes to choosing between adjustable dumbbells and fixed dumbbells for your home gym, personal preferences and considerations play a significant role. Here are some factors to consider:

Weight Range

If you are a beginner, you probably don't need a wide range of weights, two or three sets of dumbells might be fine, in this case, I would go with fixed dumbells. However, if you are an experienced lifter, adjustable dumbbells may be the best option as they offer a wider range of weights.

Space

If you have limited space in your home gym, adjustable dumbbells may be a better choice as they take up less space than a full set of fixed dumbbells. However, if you have plenty of space, fixed dumbbells may be more convenient as you don't have to adjust the weight every time you switch exercises.

Versatility

Adjustable dumbbells offer more versatility as you can change the weight easily and quickly, allowing you to perform a wide range of exercises with a single pair of dumbbells. Fixed dumbbells, on the other hand, are limited to a specific weight, which can limit your exercise options.

Personal Trainer

If you are working with a personal trainer, they may recommend a specific type of dumbbell based on your fitness goals and needs. It's essential to consider their recommendations and take them into account when making your decision.

Better Option

Ultimately, the better option between adjustable dumbbells and fixed dumbbells depends on your personal preferences and needs. Consider your budget, space constraints, weight range, and versatility needs before making a decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are adjustable dumbbells safe?

Yes, adjustable dumbbells are safe to use as long as you follow the manufacturer's instructions and use them properly. It is important to make sure that the weight plates are securely fastened to the handles before use to prevent any accidents.

Are adjustable dumbbells any good?

Yes, adjustable dumbbells are a great addition to any home gym. They are versatile and can replace a whole set of fixed weights, saving you space and money. They also allow you to easily adjust the weight for different exercises and fitness levels.

What are the downsides of adjustable dumbbells?

Adjustable dumbbells, while space-saving and versatile, can be complex and time-consuming to always adjust weight in between exercises, affecting workout flow.

They often have a higher cost and potential durability issues due to plastic components in the adjustment mechanisms. Despite these factors, their convenience and range of weight options make them a popular choice for home gym enthusiasts.

Are adjustable dumbbells worth getting?

Yes, adjustable weights are worth getting if you want a versatile and space-saving option for your home gym. They may be more expensive upfront, but they can save you money in the long run by replacing a whole set of fixed dumbbells. They also allow you to easily adjust the weight for different exercises and fitness levels.

Are fixed dumbbells better?

Fixed dumbbells are a good option if you have the space and budget for a whole set of different weights. They are also more durable, balanced, and can handle more wear and tear than adjustable dumbbells. However, if space and budget are a concern, adjustable dumbbells are a great alternative.

What is the best budget option for adjustable dumbbells?

The best budget option for adjustable dumbbells is subjective and depends on your specific needs and budget. Some popular options include the Bowflex SelectTech 552, the PowerBlock Sport, and the Yes4All Adjustable Dumbbells. It is important to do your research and read reviews before making a purchase.

Before You Go...

Health Fitness